From discussion to decision: Six Thinking Hats and Quadsona for managers

Illustration of a management discussion with six coloured thinking hats on the table and a separate four-colour glass brain.

A lively meeting is not necessarily a useful one. If people leave with different ideas about what was decided, the work still has to be done.

Managers need ways to hear different perspectives, examine an issue properly and turn discussion into clear action. Safetyman Academy’s Six Thinking Hats course offers a structured thinking approach. Quadsona can complement it by helping managers reflect on the communication habits they bring to the room.

Structure the thinking, understand your contribution

Edward de Bono’s framework separates six modes: information, feelings, caution, benefits, alternatives and management of the thinking process. These are represented by white, red, black, yellow, green and blue hats respectively. The team explores a mode together rather than assigning permanent roles to different people.

Quadsona’s four personality styles serve a different purpose. They provide prompts for reflecting on tendencies, strengths and habits. Its colours do not correspond to the hats. Every participant can use every hat, whatever their Quadsona combination.

Why this matters for managers

Authority changes a conversation. When a manager announces a preferred answer first, others may spend their time supporting or resisting it. A clearer process gives people permission to contribute information, uncertainty and alternatives before the conclusion is settled.

Self-awareness helps the manager use that process consistently. If you tend to act quickly, allow space for information gathering. If you enjoy generating ideas, protect time for a decision. If you seek detail, explain which questions are essential. If you value harmony, make constructive challenge welcome.

An example: improving a recurring briefing

Imagine a team that wants to improve its daily briefing. Some colleagues think it runs too long. Others say important changes are being missed. Instead of choosing between “shorter” and “more detailed” immediately, the manager defines the decision: how can we cover the essential information in a format people can use?

The group examines what currently happens, hears reactions, considers benefits and cautions, and develops alternative formats. It may propose a short shared briefing followed by role-specific discussion. The manager records the reasons, the person responsible for preparing it and when the team will review the result.

Where a briefing concerns safety-critical work, required information, competent oversight and operational controls remain part of the decision. A thinking method helps organise discussion; technical requirements still need to be met.

Use it from the boardroom to the workplace

  • Senior leaders: separate the commercial case, available evidence, uncertainties and implementation options before approving a change.
  • Retail and hospitality managers: invite the people handling customers and deliveries to examine how a proposed process would work during a busy period.
  • Construction supervisors: use structured questions to gather practical concerns about sequencing and coordination, then refer technical or safety decisions to the appropriate competent people.
  • Energy-sector teams: bring different functions into a discussion while keeping decision authority, escalation and formal review requirements explicit.

These examples illustrate applications, not customer case studies. Choose a method and level of detail proportionate to the decision.

Make participation easier

Send essential reading in advance. State the question in one sentence. Give people a short opportunity to write down an idea before speaking. Invite quieter contributors without putting them on the spot. Record a concern accurately even when the group decides another option is preferable.

Ask about communication needs directly. Sharing a Quadsona result should remain an individual choice; effective participation should never depend on disclosing a personal report.

Check what changes after training

Choose one recurring meeting and review three things over the following month: whether decisions have clear reasons, whether actions have owners and dates, and whether participants understand what happens next. Ask what the process helped and where it became cumbersome.

Course completion is a starting point. Repeated practice, feedback and management follow-through turn a useful idea into a working habit.

Develop your managers and their teams

Explore Six Thinking Hats at Safetyman Academy. To discuss a team programme connecting learning with workplace application, contact Safetyman International.

The free Quadsona assessment offers an initial reflection on communication tendencies, with optional paid reports for further guidance. Quadsona is a division of Safetyman International Limited.

Six Thinking Hats was developed by Edward de Bono. Read the framework summary. The Quadsona applications described here are Safetyman’s own suggestions.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *